VisaTracker

Updated May 2025 · USCIS quarterly data (2023)

Country Comparison · 2023

Mexico vs Canada

Mexico had 128K immigration applications (rank #1) compared to Canada with 11K (rank #17). Mexico has a 99% approval rate while Canada has 74%. Mexico sends substantially more immigration applications to USCIS than Canada — 128K versus 11K, a ratio of more than 11.5 to one. The gap reflects population, diaspora ties, and historical immigration patterns rather than any policy distinction in how the two countries are treated.

Verdict

Mexico had 128K immigration applications (rank #1) compared to Canada with 11K (rank #17). Mexico has a 99% approval rate while Canada has 74%.

Comparing Mexico and Canada on USCIS immigration data requires looking at three things: application volume, approval rate, and the mix of visa categories that applicants from each country tend to use. The per-country pages cover each axis in detail; the comparison below summarizes the highest-impact differences.

Country-specific quota dynamics, particularly for family-based and employment-based green cards, can produce very different actual timelines from the headline USCIS processing times. The State Department Visa Bulletin governs when an applicant from a backlogged country can move to the next stage; the headline USCIS processing-time data does not capture that priority-date wait.

Side-by-Side Snapshot

MetricMexicoCanada
Total Applications128K11K
Approval Rate99%74%
Country Rank#1#17
Visa Categories55

How Mexico and Canada Compare on Volume

Mexico sends substantially more immigration applications to USCIS than Canada — 128K versus 11K, a ratio of more than 11.5 to one. The gap reflects population, diaspora ties, and historical immigration patterns rather than any policy distinction in how the two countries are treated.

Mexico sits well above Canada in the overall application ranking — #1 versus #17 of 198 tracked countries. The gap is wide enough that the two origins occupy different tiers of the U.S. immigration pipeline; Mexico is among the largest sending countries while Canada sits further down the list. For broader context on long-run migration patterns by origin country, the DHS Yearbook of Immigration Statistics publishes annual flow data going back decades, and the U.S. Department of State publishes the monthly Visa Bulletin that governs visa availability under the per-country numerical caps in the Immigration and Nationality Act.

How They Compare on Approval Rate

Mexico's 99% approval rate runs 25 points above Canada's 74% — a wide spread that typically signals either a meaningfully different visa-type mix between the two countries, or substantive differences in eligibility documentation common to filings from each origin. Mexico sits in the very high approval tier while Canada is in the mixed tier.

Approval rates are computed by U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) as approved cases divided by completed cases, excluding still-pending applications. Cross-country gaps usually trace to one of three factors: the visa-type mix (family-sponsored petitions approve at higher rates than employment-based or humanitarian filings), documentation patterns common to filings from a given origin, or eligibility-criteria gaps surfaced during background checks. None of these are policy choices specific to a country — USCIS adjudication standards are uniform across origins.

Top Visa Types

Both countries' largest visa category is Family Spouse, accounting for 53K Mexico filings and 4.4K Canada filings. Shared dominant categories usually reflect a common driver — most often family reunification, employment-based migration in shared labor markets, or temporary worker programs that span both origins.

Mexico

Family Spouse53K
Family Parents32K
Family 2nd Pref16K
Family Children9.1K
Employment 3rd Pref4.0K

Canada

Family Spouse4.4K
Employment 2nd Pref1.9K
Employment 3rd Pref1.7K
Employment 1st Pref1.5K
Family Children533

How This Comparison Is Calculated

Application counts are aggregated from USCIS quarterly performance disclosures for fiscal year 2023, summing across all visa categories filed by beneficiaries from each country. Approval rate is computed as approved cases divided by completed cases (approvals plus denials), excluding still-pending applications. Country rank orders all 198 tracked sending countries by total applications, with #1 being the highest-volume origin. The DHS Yearbook of Immigration Statistics provides cross-checks against historical baselines. Read the full VisaTracker methodology for definitions, edge cases, and refresh cadence.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does Mexico have more applications than Canada?

Mexico sends substantially more immigration applications to USCIS than Canada — 128K versus 11K, a ratio of more than 11.5 to one. The gap reflects population, diaspora ties, and historical immigration patterns rather than any policy distinction in how the two countries are treated. Differences this size usually reflect population, diaspora networks, and historical migration patterns rather than any policy distinction in how the two countries are treated. The U.S. State Department and DHS Yearbook of Immigration Statistics publish historical context on the long-run drivers of country-by-country volume.

Why are approval rates different between Mexico and Canada?

Mexico's 99% approval rate runs 25 points above Canada's 74% — a wide spread that typically signals either a meaningfully different visa-type mix between the two countries, or substantive differences in eligibility documentation common to filings from each origin. Mexico sits in the very high approval tier while Canada is in the mixed tier. The composition of visa-type filings is the largest single driver: countries weighted toward family-sponsored or diversity-visa categories typically post higher approval rates than countries weighted toward employment-based, asylum, or refugee filings, where eligibility analysis is heavier.

What types of visas dominate Mexico and Canada filings?

Both countries' largest visa category is Family Spouse, accounting for 53K Mexico filings and 4.4K Canada filings. Shared dominant categories usually reflect a common driver — most often family reunification, employment-based migration in shared labor markets, or temporary worker programs that span both origins. Reviewing each country's full visa-type distribution on its country profile gives a clearer picture of the underlying migration story.

Where does this comparison data come from?

Application counts and approval rates come from USCIS quarterly disclosure data, supplemented by the DHS Yearbook of Immigration Statistics published by the Office of Homeland Security Statistics. Both are public-domain U.S. government sources. This comparison aggregates filings by beneficiary country of birth or country of chargeability as reported in those datasets.

Is this comparison giving immigration advice?

No. This is general data analysis of public USCIS records, not legal advice. The comparison does not reflect individual case factors like beneficiary qualifications, priority dates, country-cap effects under the Immigration and Nationality Act, or the practical wait times specific to a particular visa category. For guidance on a specific case, consult an immigration attorney or an accredited representative recognized by the U.S. Department of Justice.

Explore More

Mexico profile|Canada profile|All country rankings|Methodology

Sources: U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) quarterly performance data for fiscal year 2023; DHS Office of Homeland Security Statistics, Yearbook of Immigration Statistics; U.S. Department of State, Bureau of Consular Affairs. All inputs are public-domain U.S. government data.

Cite as: "VisaTracker, Mexico vs Canada comparison, May 2025. Data: USCIS quarterly performance reports, fiscal year 2023."