Withholding of Removal

What It Means

Withholding of removal under INA section 241(b)(3) implements the U.S. non-refoulement obligation under Article 33 of the 1951 Refugee Convention. Unlike asylum, which is discretionary, withholding is mandatory if the applicant meets the higher evidentiary standard of showing a "clear probability" (more likely than not) that their life or freedom would be threatened in the proposed country of removal on account of race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group. There is a parallel Convention Against Torture (CAT) protection under 8 CFR 208.16-18 that requires a showing that the applicant is more likely than not to be tortured by or with the consent or acquiescence of a public official. Withholding has significant disadvantages compared to asylum: it applies only to the specific country of feared persecution (so the U.S. could still remove to a third country), it does not provide a path to LPR status or U.S. citizenship, it does not allow derivative status for spouses or children, and it does not permit international travel without risking loss of protection. Withholding recipients do receive work authorization under 8 CFR 274a.12(a)(10) and protection from removal to the designated country. The 1-year filing deadline for asylum under INA section 208(a)(2)(B) does not apply to withholding, making it the primary option for applicants who miss the asylum deadline. Certain bars apply to both asylum and withholding (particular serious crime, persecution of others, danger to national security), and the particularly serious crime bar is construed more narrowly for withholding.

Frequently Asked Questions

Related Terms